Hot Topics: Winter Ate My Garage Floor Hot Topics: Winter Ate My Garage Floor

Here on DoItYourself.com we enjoy providing a place where home improvement novices and experts can come together to share ideas and advice. Inside our Forums, users can browse threads to see what exchanges are taking place on a topic of interest or start their own dialogue by posting something for the community to take part in. With over 250,000 members and counting, this resource is quite active so each week we highlight one of the conversations that may just help you with that next DIY project.

Winter’s done a number on most of the country, so this poster can’t be the only person with freeze/thaw issues in his concrete. Once erosion has a foothold, how do you get ahead of it? Ask the Forum.

Original Post: Concrete chipping away at front edge of garage floor

GillyWI Member

Our 20-year-old home has had an ongoing problem with bits and pieces of the garage floor chipping/breaking (where the floor meets the driveway, under the garage door weatherstrip). I took out the broken stuff and filled with sand, then covered with patching cement and that was OK for a year or so, but it will be time to take action again.

I am considering having and expert cut out this whole strip (side to side) and re-pour the section. Just thought maybe there was another way to go about it. Doing these small areas doesn't seem to last and we'd like a more permanent/professional repair.

Highlights from the Thread

GillyWI Member

Bear in mind I did repair this once, so the affected areas are now the patching cement, not the original. Looked pretty much the same before I repaired it the first time.

Don't have a problem calling in an expert (saw, jackhammer, cement truck, etc) if that's what it takes. Just looking for opinions.

Hot Topics, Winter Ate My Garage Floor, concrete

The first pic is a bit to the right of where my pickups tires enter the garage, the second pic you can sort of see tire tracks from my wife’s car, so this area is about in the middle of where her tires are, so I don't think it's caused by tires, may just be freeze/thaw related?

BridgeMan45 Member

I spent almost 8 years of my professional DOT career working with concrete problems in Wisconsin. I see a lot of chert pop-outs in your garage floor, and an indication that the overall concrete quality was possibly a bit low in cement content and has too much fine aggregate (not enough rock). It shows up in the wheel paths for obvious reasons, evolving into "D"-shaped spalling as yours is doing.

A proper fix would include making a sawcut several inches deep parallel to the door and expansion joint filler, but at least 8 or 9 inches back from the joint. Doing so will put the new junction between new and existing well inside the garage, instead of outside where it's exposed to the elements. Go down at least 3 inches with complete removal, using small chipping hammers to take everything out. Go much shallower (like your first repair appears to be), and you'll be doing it all again in a few years. Sand-blast to squeaky-clean condition, followed by first wetting and then applying a neat Portland cement slurry bonding agent, before immediately applying your new concrete. Don't drive on it for at least 4 or 5 days.

There isn't enough quantity to warrant using commercial ready-mix, far less than a yard, so just batch your own using a quality sack-mix, possibly sweetened with some additional Portland cement in each batch.

GillyWI Member

Thanks much, that's pretty much what I had assumed I had to do, appreciate the explanation. Yes I didn't remove very much at all, just what I could pick out and maybe chiseled a few pieces out that looked suspect.

There is some construction going on here again. I had a little work done before at the driveway apron where a concrete company said they would have some extra concrete on a truck in the area they could have available, maybe that could happen again.

landfillwizard Member

The only thing I would add to Bridgeman's comments is to make sure the material you use is a sidewalk mix with entrained air. The entrained air makes the concrete more durable in cold weather. Also if you get the material off a truck, see how long the material had been batched. If it is longer than 90 minutes there may be problems. Also if the slump is less than 2 inches don't add any more water! This will weaken the compressive strength of the concrete.

Read more: http://www.doityourself.com/forum/bricks-masonry-asphalt-concrete/520530-concrete-chipping-away-front-edge-garage-floor.html#ixzz2vxUtCzvI

Got a New Project You're Proud of?

Post it on Your Projects!