Problem with Goodman Furnace/AC System
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 5
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Problem with Goodman Furnace/AC System
Ok, have a Goodman GMNT080-4b Furnace/Air handler. We bought the house last summer, and AC was fine for the rest of the summer, Heat worked just fine all winter. When we went to turn it back to ac, the outside unit starts as normal, inside unit started up, we get good cool air, for about 3-5 minutes, then the indoor blower cuts off. Turns back on a few seconds later. This repeats with shortening time of the blower running, till I cut it off.
The diagnostic light on the control board is on constantly, showing normal operation. It never blinks any codes.
Started out checking for anything burnt, loose, etc. And haven't found anything amiss. Went ahead and replaced the capacitor, with no change. Tested the motor with an ohm-meter, and all the values seem to add up:
Common to Run -- 2.3, Start to Common -- 3.4, Start to Run 5.5, so was assuming motor was ok.
So was thinking it had to be in control board, so rigged up an external switch to test the blower. Turned on switch, blower ran for 5 minutes straight, about till I thought I'd figured it out, then cut off. Flipped switch off, and immediately back on and blower started up again immediately. The only thing I can think of to cause it to switch off now, would be a thermal shutdown within the motor itself. Ran it again till it quit on its own, noticed there was a slight squeal or whistle just before the motor shut off. Immediately opened the panels to check the temp of the motor, and only 30 seconds after it shuts down the motor is only slightly warm to the touch, not near scalding like I would expect (I have a large fan that would burn you in comparison when it has been on for a while).
So any ideas on what I should look for next? If it really is the blower motor how can I make sure besides replacing it? If not what else is the likely cause?
Appreciate any help you can give.
The diagnostic light on the control board is on constantly, showing normal operation. It never blinks any codes.
Started out checking for anything burnt, loose, etc. And haven't found anything amiss. Went ahead and replaced the capacitor, with no change. Tested the motor with an ohm-meter, and all the values seem to add up:
Common to Run -- 2.3, Start to Common -- 3.4, Start to Run 5.5, so was assuming motor was ok.
So was thinking it had to be in control board, so rigged up an external switch to test the blower. Turned on switch, blower ran for 5 minutes straight, about till I thought I'd figured it out, then cut off. Flipped switch off, and immediately back on and blower started up again immediately. The only thing I can think of to cause it to switch off now, would be a thermal shutdown within the motor itself. Ran it again till it quit on its own, noticed there was a slight squeal or whistle just before the motor shut off. Immediately opened the panels to check the temp of the motor, and only 30 seconds after it shuts down the motor is only slightly warm to the touch, not near scalding like I would expect (I have a large fan that would burn you in comparison when it has been on for a while).
So any ideas on what I should look for next? If it really is the blower motor how can I make sure besides replacing it? If not what else is the likely cause?
Appreciate any help you can give.
#2
It must be the motor since you wired it hot directly. FYI, that furnace is known to have heat exchanger problems. I would not sink too much money in it until it was checked by a professional.
#3
These motors are designed to operate against static pressure.
Was this motor installed in the furnace during this test?
Was this motor installed in the furnace during this test?
#4
Member
Join Date: Feb 2010
Location: usa
Posts: 616
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
It must be the circuit board. Because the fan would not come back on immediately if it were a thermal problem. When the fan goes off, is the outdoor unit still running? When the blower shuts off do you still have 120 volts going to it?
#5
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 5
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Goodman Furnace/AC System
ender2272
It must be the circuit board. Because the fan would not come back on immediately if it were a thermal problem. When the fan goes off, is the outdoor unit still running? When the blower shuts off do you still have 120 volts going to it?
It must be the circuit board. Because the fan would not come back on immediately if it were a thermal problem. When the fan goes off, is the outdoor unit still running? When the blower shuts off do you still have 120 volts going to it?
Houston204
These motors are designed to operate against static pressure.
Was this motor installed in the furnace during this test?
These motors are designed to operate against static pressure.
Was this motor installed in the furnace during this test?
#6
Jumper R and G to rule out a bad connection at the t-stat or board.
If the fan stays on, the board and motor are fine.
If not, check for voltage between the cooling terminal and neutral with the t-stat calling for cooling, the motor disconnected, and the power to the outdoor unit off.
If it doesn't drop out, the board is good.
If the fan stays on, the board and motor are fine.
If not, check for voltage between the cooling terminal and neutral with the t-stat calling for cooling, the motor disconnected, and the power to the outdoor unit off.
If it doesn't drop out, the board is good.
#7
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 5
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Testing
Muggle
Jumper R and G to rule out a bad connection at the t-stat or board.
If the fan stays on, the board and motor are fine.
Jumper R and G to rule out a bad connection at the t-stat or board.
If the fan stays on, the board and motor are fine.
If not, check for voltage between the cooling terminal and neutral with the t-stat calling for cooling, the motor disconnected, and the power to the outdoor unit off.
If it doesn't drop out, the board is good
If it doesn't drop out, the board is good
Edited: Figured it out after re-reading the wiring diagram a few times.
T-stat in cooling mode, blower motor and condensing unit disconnected. 28.3 VAC between Y from the furnace, and common/ground.
So does that sound like the control board is good and the motor is shot?
Last edited by james404; 04-30-12 at 12:18 AM.
#8
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 5
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Another bit of info: Like I said the furnace had worked all winter long, seemingly ok. So just tried another test, moved the fan speed that was used for heat (orange wire, med-lo) to the cool terminal. Did the R/G short and put power back. Fan ran for 15 minutes, no sign of shutdown, till I finally killed power.
So I guess that was at least long enough for the heat cycle to complete, before the motor shutdown, or at least as we'd noticed it.
I'm so tempted to leave it like that and turn on the AC tonight
but better judgment must prevail.
So I guess that was at least long enough for the heat cycle to complete, before the motor shutdown, or at least as we'd noticed it.
I'm so tempted to leave it like that and turn on the AC tonight

#9
Connect the black wire to the heating terminal and run the furnace for a few minutes.
If it still cycles, the motor is overheating and shutting down.
Ensure that the motor openings are clear and look for oiling ports - if they exist, add a couple of drops of electric motor oil. (How to Lubricate a Furnace Blower Motor | eHow.com)
If that doesn't work, the motor is probably bad.
Doing that may freeze the coil.
Try medium high. (I think it's yellow or brown - check schematic)
If it still cycles, the motor is overheating and shutting down.
Ensure that the motor openings are clear and look for oiling ports - if they exist, add a couple of drops of electric motor oil. (How to Lubricate a Furnace Blower Motor | eHow.com)
If that doesn't work, the motor is probably bad.
I'm so tempted to leave it like that and turn on the AC tonight but better judgment must prevail.
Read more: http://www.doityourself.com/forum/ne...#ixzz1tVfJ12MR
Read more: http://www.doityourself.com/forum/ne...#ixzz1tVfJ12MR
Try medium high. (I think it's yellow or brown - check schematic)
#10
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Apr 2012
Posts: 5
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Doing that may freeze the coil.
Try medium high. (I think it's yellow or brown - check schematic)
Try medium high. (I think it's yellow or brown - check schematic)
Connect the black wire to the heating terminal and run the furnace for a few minutes.
...
Ensure that the motor openings are clear and look for oiling ports - if they exist, add a couple of drops of electric motor oil.
If that doesn't work, the motor is probably bad.
...
Ensure that the motor openings are clear and look for oiling ports - if they exist, add a couple of drops of electric motor oil.
If that doesn't work, the motor is probably bad.

#11
I think your unit has the older goodman heat exchanger which according to others on this board is prone to cracking and popping crimp rings. (new model numbers start with gks, gmh, gmvc)
I would pull the blower assembly and check the heat exchanger prior to investing in a new motor.
I would pull the blower assembly and check the heat exchanger prior to investing in a new motor.