Attic Ventilation
#1
Attic Ventilation
I'm looking to improve the ventilation in the attic of a 1960's ranch. The roof is a simple gable with currently very little soffit venting and a single gable vent with fan. There are no particular issues other than heat (no mold, frost, etc), so just trying to be proactive.
The first step will be to add some additional soffit vents at the front and back of the house. Then come the questions.
I am going back and forth between a powered roof vent or 3 or 4 standard roof vents. I'd rather not go with a ridge vent as I'm not sure I can install it myself. I can handle normal vents though.
Once I install the extra soffit vents and some type of top of roof vent, what should happen with the gable vent?
Any other suggestions?
Thanks in advance,
Mike
The first step will be to add some additional soffit vents at the front and back of the house. Then come the questions.
I am going back and forth between a powered roof vent or 3 or 4 standard roof vents. I'd rather not go with a ridge vent as I'm not sure I can install it myself. I can handle normal vents though.
Once I install the extra soffit vents and some type of top of roof vent, what should happen with the gable vent?
Any other suggestions?
Thanks in advance,
Mike
#4
I'll go out on the shaky limb and state that in my opinion passive ventilation is always better than mechanical ventilation as long as you can get sufficient air flow. Not much worse than to have to replace a motor in a hot attic in August to say nothing of the cost for the electricity to run the motor. Solar powered attic fans are a joke as far as I am concerned.
#5
The first step will be to add some additional soffit vents at the front and back of the house. Then come the questions.
I am going back and forth between a powered roof vent or 3 or 4 standard roof vents. I'd rather not go with a ridge vent as I'm not sure I can install it myself. I can handle normal vents though.
I am going back and forth between a powered roof vent or 3 or 4 standard roof vents. I'd rather not go with a ridge vent as I'm not sure I can install it myself. I can handle normal vents though.
Don't punch holes in a good roof.
Heat in an attic is not a problem. condensation and uneven roof heating in the winter are.
#6
"Heat in an attic is not a problem." Well, if one isn't concerned with the heat making it hard to keep the house cool in summer, or doesn't care about shortening the life of the roof's shingles, then yes, maybe it isn't a problem.
For the rest of us, using natural ventilation to keep the attic cool is a big plus. I've always been inclined to using wind turbines combined with adequate soffit vents myself, as they do a great job at zero operating expense in removing excessive heat from the attic. I'd swear one could boil eggs from the heat spitting out at each spinning vent on a warm summer day at my place in Albuquerque, NM. Used solid galvanized steel covers to replace them each winter, when it was advantageous to allow some heat to accumulate in the attic. I later helped a buddy install ridge vents on his place in SW Colorado, and he grumbled for months that they weren't very effective in cooling his attic, even though he had lots of soffit vents. His wife didn't want wind turbines because she didn't like the way they looked, even though they could have been hidden from the street.
For the rest of us, using natural ventilation to keep the attic cool is a big plus. I've always been inclined to using wind turbines combined with adequate soffit vents myself, as they do a great job at zero operating expense in removing excessive heat from the attic. I'd swear one could boil eggs from the heat spitting out at each spinning vent on a warm summer day at my place in Albuquerque, NM. Used solid galvanized steel covers to replace them each winter, when it was advantageous to allow some heat to accumulate in the attic. I later helped a buddy install ridge vents on his place in SW Colorado, and he grumbled for months that they weren't very effective in cooling his attic, even though he had lots of soffit vents. His wife didn't want wind turbines because she didn't like the way they looked, even though they could have been hidden from the street.
#7
Wind turbines are great IF you have enough wind to cause them to spin, otherwise they are just plain ugly. If they are steel they will eventually rust. When the bearings go they squeak. They WILL move a lot of air provided you have sufficient intake (soffit) vents. Nonetheless they cannot do any more than bring the attic temperature down to the ambient air temperature.
Full ridge venting along with adequate soffit venting will do almost as well as a wind turbine and will do it in absolute dead calm wind conditions if properly installed. You should not use high gable end vents along with a ridge vent system because the air will "short circuit" from the gable vent to the ridge vent.
Full ridge venting along with adequate soffit venting will do almost as well as a wind turbine and will do it in absolute dead calm wind conditions if properly installed. You should not use high gable end vents along with a ridge vent system because the air will "short circuit" from the gable vent to the ridge vent.
#8
"Heat in an attic is not a problem."
using natural ventilation... is a big plus.
Well, if one isn't concerned with the heat making it hard to keep the house cool in summer, or doesn't care about shortening the life of the roof's shingles, then yes, maybe it isn't a problem.
Turbine vents, turtle vents and similar roof-hole vents are possibly one step better than powered attic exhaust fans, but not by much. As Furd pointed out, they are just plain ugly and they will eventually rust, and fail. In addition, they require punching holes in an otherwise good roof, they are non-continuous, and, most importantly, they are installed below the peak of the roof. That means that the hottest air in the attic will remain there, above those vents, tight up under the ridge.
@Zorfdt: If you want to improve the ventilation in the attic of your 1960's ranch house with a simple gable roof, very little soffit venting and a single gable vent with fan

And as Larry said,
Please don't punch holes in a perfectly good roof

#11
I think an important point is the fact that some ridge vent brands/designs are considerably better than others. The type with a dense, black plastic woven-type foam doesn't allow much air movement through it at all--I helped a neighbor install one on his house (he chose it and bought it before asking for my help), and on a cool but sunny day when the attic was roasting, you couldn't feel hardly any warm air moving through it out of the attic. By contrast, on that same day, I took the neighbor up on my roof to show him how much hot attic air was rushing out of my trusty wind turbines. The words he uttered can't be printed here.
And regarding corrosion possibilities mentioned by some posters--most turbines these days are made of aluminum, so rusting is not a problem. Just a few drops of light oil in the bearing assembly once a year is all the maintenance they ever need.
And regarding corrosion possibilities mentioned by some posters--most turbines these days are made of aluminum, so rusting is not a problem. Just a few drops of light oil in the bearing assembly once a year is all the maintenance they ever need.
#12
Maybe but there's a lot more surface area to the ridge vent than the turbines with the number I've ever seen on a roof so the air would not need to move as fast through the ridge vent to move the same cfm.