Go Back  DoItYourself.com Community Forums > Interior Improvement Center > Basements, Attics and Crawl Spaces
Reload this Page >

Replacing Basement Insulation - Worth it or safe?

Replacing Basement Insulation - Worth it or safe?


  #1  
Old 10-29-22, 06:54 PM
R
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jun 2015
Location: USA
Posts: 62
Received 1 Upvote on 1 Post
Replacing Basement Insulation - Worth it or safe?

I have some ragged and old looking insulation in the ceiling of my late 1950's basement around the perimeter of the house and wondered if replacing it was worth it (aesthetics and better insulation), and more importantly safe - I wasn't sure if this contained asbestos. Any opinions would be great. We're looking to sell in a couple years and wouldn't know if I'd have an issue with the inspector for any reason. Thanks!



 

Top Answer

 
10-29-22, 08:49 PM
CarbideTipped
CarbideTipped is offline
Member
Join Date: May 2015
Location: USA
Posts: 3,107
Received 145 Upvotes on 118 Posts
That's just fiberglass insulation. No asbestos. Installed poorly. It's not really a safety issue, but it's not doing its job and you are wasting some heating/cooling. Insulation of the rim joist area, which is what your photos show, is intended to prevent heat(or cool) loss to the outside. Chances are, when your house was built there was no insulation there and someone added it later. So, what to do? You could leave it. I doubt an inspector would flag it as a serious issue; but they might note it. Or you could remove it and do a proper job of replacing it. We now know that rim joist insulation serves two purposes: It slows down heat loss/gain to the outside through that area, and it prevents condensation on the inside of the rim joist where it can eventually lead to wood rot. This is mostly an issue in areas where it gets cold outside. The rim joist gets cold, and warm, moist air from the inside reaches the rim joist and the water vapor condenses on the surface. A good insulation job does both those jobs. Best practice is probably a couple inches of spray foam against the joist and then the remainder of the space is often filled with rock wool or fiberglass. Another way to do the foam is to cut pieces of 2" thick rigid foam a little undersize, place it in the cavity, and then seal all around it with can foam so there is no way warm air can reach the rim joist. Spray foam can be a DIY job, but it's fussy and really messy. The cut and cobble method using rigid foam and can foam is an easier DIY, but still has to be done carefully.
 
  #2  
Old 10-29-22, 08:49 PM
C
Member
Join Date: May 2015
Location: USA
Posts: 3,107
Received 145 Upvotes on 118 Posts
That's just fiberglass insulation. No asbestos. Installed poorly. It's not really a safety issue, but it's not doing its job and you are wasting some heating/cooling. Insulation of the rim joist area, which is what your photos show, is intended to prevent heat(or cool) loss to the outside. Chances are, when your house was built there was no insulation there and someone added it later. So, what to do? You could leave it. I doubt an inspector would flag it as a serious issue; but they might note it. Or you could remove it and do a proper job of replacing it. We now know that rim joist insulation serves two purposes: It slows down heat loss/gain to the outside through that area, and it prevents condensation on the inside of the rim joist where it can eventually lead to wood rot. This is mostly an issue in areas where it gets cold outside. The rim joist gets cold, and warm, moist air from the inside reaches the rim joist and the water vapor condenses on the surface. A good insulation job does both those jobs. Best practice is probably a couple inches of spray foam against the joist and then the remainder of the space is often filled with rock wool or fiberglass. Another way to do the foam is to cut pieces of 2" thick rigid foam a little undersize, place it in the cavity, and then seal all around it with can foam so there is no way warm air can reach the rim joist. Spray foam can be a DIY job, but it's fussy and really messy. The cut and cobble method using rigid foam and can foam is an easier DIY, but still has to be done carefully.
 
jeweler, RickyL voted this post useful.
 

Thread Tools
Search this Thread
 
Ask a Question
Question Title:
Description:
Your question will be posted in: