Allowing a field stone foundation to breathe? Can i re-point?
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: USA
Posts: 6
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts

Hi All,
This is my first post, this forum has been very useful to me in the past!
I want to re-point a field stone basement foundation (to avoid smells, insects and bats entering), the stone was never given a mortar, I'm wondering.. why they didn't? I'm worried it was for a reason.
My question is: If i go ahead and use a lime mortar and re-point, will i be restricting the buildings ability to breath? Or anything else i have not thought of. It is a 100 y/o + barn / building made from wood with a dirt floor I also intend to finish soon.
The ground level is in the photo shown by an arrow. Thank you in advance - G
This is my first post, this forum has been very useful to me in the past!
I want to re-point a field stone basement foundation (to avoid smells, insects and bats entering), the stone was never given a mortar, I'm wondering.. why they didn't? I'm worried it was for a reason.
My question is: If i go ahead and use a lime mortar and re-point, will i be restricting the buildings ability to breath? Or anything else i have not thought of. It is a 100 y/o + barn / building made from wood with a dirt floor I also intend to finish soon.
The ground level is in the photo shown by an arrow. Thank you in advance - G

#3
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: USA
Posts: 6
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Hi Pulpo,
The only things entering have been bats, which my wife adores.
It is a lot of work, I'm just wondering if insects and smells come through the large gaps in-between some of the larger stones.
Maybe I should finish the floor first, block obvious bat entry holes after they leave and see how that effects the musk smell down there? Maybe there is no real point besides aesthetics.
Do you see any issues with doing it, like the building breathing?
What would you suggest?
Thanks
G
The only things entering have been bats, which my wife adores.
It is a lot of work, I'm just wondering if insects and smells come through the large gaps in-between some of the larger stones.
Maybe I should finish the floor first, block obvious bat entry holes after they leave and see how that effects the musk smell down there? Maybe there is no real point besides aesthetics.
Do you see any issues with doing it, like the building breathing?
What would you suggest?
Thanks
G
#4
Not sure if this is of any help, buy check this video: Insulation, Foundation | Ask TOH Episodes | Ask This Old House TV | This Old House Go to scene 4.
#7
Member
Join Date: Jul 2013
Posts: 143
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Anybody else think it was funny that he turned his nose up at a past DIY effort to patch a section of the wall because it used a harder Portland-based mortar that was incompatible with the original stuff, then proceeded to whip up a batch of pre-mix type S from the local big box store?
Last edited by eharri3; 01-19-14 at 04:51 PM.
#8
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jan 2014
Location: USA
Posts: 6
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
OK, so Lime mortar for this old stone application! To avoid cracks during movements, right? Anyone have a favorite recipe specific to field stone & sub floor basements? I would like to live in / use this room. I have heard of 1 part lime to three parts sharp sand, one part cement?
Questions;
1. What proportions do YOU advise?
2. What is this business of leaving the lime in water for a while? one person even mentioned weeks!
3. I picked up a bag of lime at the local co-op It does have a "general" recipe: sand, lime and a small amount of cement. It makes no mention of curing the lime, how come?
4. Any need for elmers glue, or adhesive to help it stick?
5. Should i brush it off with a large wet brush to smooth the finish, how long after should i do that?
Pulpo and Ironhand.. This old house was amazing as usual, and the simplicity with which the basement floor was finished gave the boss (Mrs) much confidence in the whole idea.. So pleased this season is back finishing a non-Scandinavian house, especially in my neck of the woods.
Thanks again!!
G
Questions;
1. What proportions do YOU advise?
2. What is this business of leaving the lime in water for a while? one person even mentioned weeks!
3. I picked up a bag of lime at the local co-op It does have a "general" recipe: sand, lime and a small amount of cement. It makes no mention of curing the lime, how come?
4. Any need for elmers glue, or adhesive to help it stick?
5. Should i brush it off with a large wet brush to smooth the finish, how long after should i do that?
Pulpo and Ironhand.. This old house was amazing as usual, and the simplicity with which the basement floor was finished gave the boss (Mrs) much confidence in the whole idea.. So pleased this season is back finishing a non-Scandinavian house, especially in my neck of the woods.
Thanks again!!
G