Aluminum versus steel handrail

Hi, My house is 40 years old and the posts for the iron handrail on my 7 front entrance steps are rusted in multiple places, mostly where the post meets the concrete. A contractor is suggesting that I let him cut it all off and replace with an aluminum handrail. I understand I wouldn't have to paint it regularly and it wouldn't rust, but will it be a strong? If I lose my balance an fall towards it, will it hold me or will it bend?

Is there any such thing as a stainless steel handrail that comes in black with vertical rails and not horizontal rods? Thanks.

 

Generally speaking, anything horizontal on a railing fails current code as it allows a child to climb. Can you post a picture of what you have?

 

I don't like horizontal rods anyway; I prefer the black vertical pickets you see below, but I've not see stainless steel with vertical pickets, just wire or horizontal rods as in the bottom image.

 

It all depends on the fencing used. A aluminum fence can be stronger or weaker. It just depends on how it's built, how thick is the metal, how is it attached...? I would say in general aluminum railing options tend to be lower cost and more lightly constructed though I have seen very high quality aluminum railings. Again, it all depends on what you buy.

I have stainless steel railings on my porch so it can be done. I have never seen is available in a big box store. I made mine. Stainless is usually expensive but right now prices are very high so expect sticker shock when you see the price.