ticking, popping, and clanging/banging in ductwork below bedroom
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2020
Posts: 8
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
ticking, popping, and clanging/banging in ductwork below bedroom
We recently moved into a home and noticed immediately that the ductwork is noisy when the heat kicks in. We sometimes notice it in other rooms, but for the most part the problem is limited to the master bedroom. We have a zoned system (3 floors, one zone per floor), and when any of the zones calls for heat, we hear ticking in one particular spot under the master bedroom floor, along with banging/clanging sounds in a couple different areas under the floor. It's quite frustrating and we'd like to find a definitive solution to this problem.
We first called in a contractor who "thought" he knew how to fix it. That involved pulling up the carpet in the master bedroom, cutting up the floor, and adding padding between the ductwork and the floor. I think he made some other adjustments as well, but none of that changed the situation at all.
I've called a number of other HVAC companies. Most tell me they have no idea how to fix, but could look if we have someone first remove the drywall in the room(s) below the master bedroom. One company told us that sealing the ductwork should fix it, but they are quoting $3.5k to do it, and I'm hesitant to sink that much money into the problem unless i have a guaranteed solution.
So at this point, I'm trying desperately to figure out the cause of and solution to this problem. Ideally someone who has dealt with this before who can come in and say "here's the cause, here's how i'll fix it, and it will cost x dollars".
Any ideas? Anyone know how to proceed?
We first called in a contractor who "thought" he knew how to fix it. That involved pulling up the carpet in the master bedroom, cutting up the floor, and adding padding between the ductwork and the floor. I think he made some other adjustments as well, but none of that changed the situation at all.
I've called a number of other HVAC companies. Most tell me they have no idea how to fix, but could look if we have someone first remove the drywall in the room(s) below the master bedroom. One company told us that sealing the ductwork should fix it, but they are quoting $3.5k to do it, and I'm hesitant to sink that much money into the problem unless i have a guaranteed solution.
So at this point, I'm trying desperately to figure out the cause of and solution to this problem. Ideally someone who has dealt with this before who can come in and say "here's the cause, here's how i'll fix it, and it will cost x dollars".
Any ideas? Anyone know how to proceed?
#2
No one can say "here's the problem" without seeing it and that isn't going to be easy to find if it's buried in the floors and walls.
Leaky ductwork does not make any noise so sealing up the ductwork will yield no improvement.
You say you have a zoned system and from your description it sounds like a loose damper.
That would certainly make noise. Typically the dampers are installed so as to be able to service them.
Do you know where they are ?
Leaky ductwork does not make any noise so sealing up the ductwork will yield no improvement.
You say you have a zoned system and from your description it sounds like a loose damper.
That would certainly make noise. Typically the dampers are installed so as to be able to service them.
Do you know where they are ?
#3
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2020
Posts: 8
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Thanks for the quick response!
Indeed I do know where all of the dampers are, and they are accessible. At least I think I have access to all of them. I did play around with the dampers a bit and noted that they were all open, but I’m not certain if they are loose or not. I suppose I should look at that more closely..
Assuming I can confirm that the dampers are not loose, what is another likely cause? I’ll say that the ticking noise does kind of sound like it could be damper related, but the “banging” noise does not. Also, the ductwork is silent when I run the a/c or just the blower fan (without heat). Heat is the only thing that seems to cause the noise.
Indeed I do know where all of the dampers are, and they are accessible. At least I think I have access to all of them. I did play around with the dampers a bit and noted that they were all open, but I’m not certain if they are loose or not. I suppose I should look at that more closely..
Assuming I can confirm that the dampers are not loose, what is another likely cause? I’ll say that the ticking noise does kind of sound like it could be damper related, but the “banging” noise does not. Also, the ductwork is silent when I run the a/c or just the blower fan (without heat). Heat is the only thing that seems to cause the noise.
#4
Hmmmm...... that is strange that you only hear the noise with heat. That would indicate a duct expansion issue. Although as the duct work expands it can make noise sliding against the framing.... it's not usually that loud.
#6
Heat is the only thing that seems to cause the noise.
We recently moved into a home
#8
how do we fix that?
#9
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2020
Posts: 8
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Well, let's say we did tear it apart and started over. How do we ensure this doesn't happen again? I guess what I'm getting at is: there _must_ be a known cause. I'm trying to determine what the cause might be, so we can address.
#10
Member
Sheet metal expands when it heats up. If it is confined so that it can't get longer/wider, what happens? It bows up or down. Ever see how they made thunder noises for the old Dracula movies? With a sheet of thin metal, press on the edges, and wave it back and forth.
The only certain way to get rid of metal expansion would be to replace the ductwork with flexible ducts. That's impractical, I suspect.
The only certain way to get rid of metal expansion would be to replace the ductwork with flexible ducts. That's impractical, I suspect.
#11
replace the ductwork with flexible ducts
Too tight, no expansion joints, not enough clearance, there is no way we will ever know what you have and how it was installed. Could it be repaired, probably, does it need to be torn out, maybe not.
Just like my comment about our noisy GEO system, I had several people out to look it over, some guys said it was the size of the duct, the blower speed, etc.
Ultimately a guy steered me right, took apart the inlet and outlet fabricated trunks, insulated the inside, 90% of noise gone! Just go to find the right solution!
#12
Square metal duct requires bends in larger sections to avoid banging.
I call them Breaks because we used to use the breaking table to make them.
We now use some giant setup that installs a different type of breaks.
If you have clearance you can screw some standing esses (kinda looks like sheet metal angle iron) to the outside every few feet to add support and stop this banging.
I call them Breaks because we used to use the breaking table to make them.
We now use some giant setup that installs a different type of breaks.
If you have clearance you can screw some standing esses (kinda looks like sheet metal angle iron) to the outside every few feet to add support and stop this banging.