Odd 3 way switch, what is wrong ?
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2018
Posts: 3
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Odd 3 way switch, what is wrong ?
I have standard setup where bulb controlled by 2 three way switches. All looks wired correctly. Yet of the four possible ways of having each of the 2 light switches be up or down , in 3 of the positions the light stays on.
Is this something seen before ? Only 1 of the boxes has a hot wire. When I took off both switches and connected hot wire to one of the traveler wires the other traveler became hot too.
This then would seem like a short. But then the two travelers should always be hot meaning the light should stay on always, not just 3 of the 4 positions.
The only thing I can think of is one traveler is shorted to the other when power goes to it but not the other way around. This seems impossible or highly unlikely.
Is this something seen before ? Only 1 of the boxes has a hot wire. When I took off both switches and connected hot wire to one of the traveler wires the other traveler became hot too.
This then would seem like a short. But then the two travelers should always be hot meaning the light should stay on always, not just 3 of the 4 positions.
The only thing I can think of is one traveler is shorted to the other when power goes to it but not the other way around. This seems impossible or highly unlikely.
#2
Member
Hi Stevie,
While we wait for the pros I'll ask, did the problem just start or did you replace something? If no wiring changes have been made I would suspect one of the two switches. I'll watch.
Bud
While we wait for the pros I'll ask, did the problem just start or did you replace something? If no wiring changes have been made I would suspect one of the two switches. I'll watch.
Bud
#3
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2018
Posts: 3
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Hi Bud,
I think it has always been this way. House was built in 2012 and we bought it 3 years ago from original owners. I don’t think they did any work on home. So I’m guessing been like this since it was new. I just got around to trying to fix it, thought it would be easy fix but am stumped. One idea is maybe something wrong at light fixture junction.
I think it has always been this way. House was built in 2012 and we bought it 3 years ago from original owners. I don’t think they did any work on home. So I’m guessing been like this since it was new. I just got around to trying to fix it, thought it would be easy fix but am stumped. One idea is maybe something wrong at light fixture junction.
#4
Member
Good morning. Be safe when working on electrical.
Here is a link to help you identify which wiring method you have.
https://www.homeimprovementweb.com/i...way-switch.htm
Bud
Thanks pc
Here is a link to help you identify which wiring method you have.
https://www.homeimprovementweb.com/i...way-switch.htm
Bud
Thanks pc
#8
Typically power only appears at one end. That wire must be on the dark/black colored screw.
Look at the two remaining wires...... those are the travelers. They should go into the same cable. That means they come out of the same cable at the other end. The remaining third wire (load/light) goes to the dark/black colored screw.
Look at the two remaining wires...... those are the travelers. They should go into the same cable. That means they come out of the same cable at the other end. The remaining third wire (load/light) goes to the dark/black colored screw.
#9
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Aug 2018
Posts: 3
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
Okay everybody. Things are working now. It was the switch. In total I had to replace three bad switches in my house. Maybe builder had a bad batch when house was built.
I was very confused though because when I removed switch and connected hot to one of the travelers I saw that the other traveler was hot. I thought just shouldn’t happen ever based on my knowledge of a 3 way switch wiring. I just tested with one of those pen things that light up red and beep when touching live wire. Maybe I messed up test though.
My father in law suggested it was the switch because he noticed light flickered when flipping light switch.
I was very confused though because when I removed switch and connected hot to one of the travelers I saw that the other traveler was hot. I thought just shouldn’t happen ever based on my knowledge of a 3 way switch wiring. I just tested with one of those pen things that light up red and beep when touching live wire. Maybe I messed up test though.
My father in law suggested it was the switch because he noticed light flickered when flipping light switch.
#10
Member
Thanks for the update. Problems often look simple once you fond the solution.
And, pick up an inexpensive analog meter, not a digital one.
Bud
And, pick up an inexpensive analog meter, not a digital one.
Bud