Trip the power off when tank is full
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Trip the power off when tank is full
Some pumps have a built in switch that trips off when the water-tank is full and I am assuming that it works on the concept of overloading.
We have a water pump that is a bit far away from the premises and have no idea when the tank gets full and needs to be turned off so it always overloads the motor, sooner or later it will burn out for sure.
So I have an idea that needs feedback or tweaking.
I am planing to install a circuit breaker before the power switch that is of the exact same amperage of the motor. So that way it should turn off when it overloads the motor.
Is it a good idea?
Did anyone try this before?
Will it work?
Please advise.
We have a water pump that is a bit far away from the premises and have no idea when the tank gets full and needs to be turned off so it always overloads the motor, sooner or later it will burn out for sure.
So I have an idea that needs feedback or tweaking.
I am planing to install a circuit breaker before the power switch that is of the exact same amperage of the motor. So that way it should turn off when it overloads the motor.
Is it a good idea?
Did anyone try this before?
Will it work?
Please advise.
#2
Member
Join Date: Feb 2016
Location: United States, Virginia
Posts: 1,704
Received 273 Upvotes
on
230 Posts
I assume this is a pressure water tank if the pressure gets to a high point it overloads the pump. If so then use a pressure switch on the tank. Never heard of electrical overloading of a pump to trip a breaker to cut power. When ever it trips you'd have to manually reset the breaker.
#3
Group Moderator
Most systems use a pressure switch. It senses the water pressure and turns the pump on and off as needed. No need for fancy electronics or current monitoring. Just a $30 mechanical switch.
#4
Member
Thread Starter
It is a normal water tank that stops with the float valve.
Many people here use the water pump with that turns off when the water tank is full but we are not using that one. It even has a small button that needs to be pressed or for the power to be recycled for it to work again.
I will try to find online the model that I am talking about and paste the link in the thread.
Many people here use the water pump with that turns off when the water tank is full but we are not using that one. It even has a small button that needs to be pressed or for the power to be recycled for it to work again.
I will try to find online the model that I am talking about and paste the link in the thread.
#5
Member
Thread Starter
To Pilot Dane.
Can you give more information on that please. It did not show up in my searches.
The plumber that came over today did not know about such a solution when I asked him about it...
Can you give more information on that please. It did not show up in my searches.
The plumber that came over today did not know about such a solution when I asked him about it...
#6
Member
Here is a pressure switch from Home Depot.
https://www.homedepot.ca/product/squ...psi/1001237628
Can you give us a better description of your tank. Is this a pressurized tank or a open tank?
https://www.homedepot.ca/product/squ...psi/1001237628
Can you give us a better description of your tank. Is this a pressurized tank or a open tank?
#7
Member
Thread Starter
It is just a normal water tank that is on the rooftop of the building. We pump water to it from the ground level water tanks.
It is not pressurized.
It is cuts off the water with a normal float valve.
Please note that I am unable to access https://www.homedepot.ca
Maybe it does not work outside of the USA.
It is not pressurized.
It is cuts off the water with a normal float valve.
Please note that I am unable to access https://www.homedepot.ca
Maybe it does not work outside of the USA.
#8
Use this link......... Pressure switches
You don't need a pressure switch with an open tank. You need a float.
Example of float
You don't need a pressure switch with an open tank. You need a float.
Example of float
#9
Member
Thread Starter
The www.homedepot.com link also gave me access denied.
The float switch seems like a good idea but it is not available in this region.
The float switch seems like a good idea but it is not available in this region.
#10
Member
Thread Starter
It is based on the "Electric Motor Reset Button" that is used for motor overheating, thermal overload protection.
Please see more details in the below link.
https://inspectapedia.com/electric/M...set_Button.php
My pump does not have that button so I want to create one.
I am assuming that it works when the motor is over working like pumping into a full water tank.
So I am thinking of installing a circuit breaker to do the same work.
I hope that it is clear and that someone can advice me on that idea.
I am planing to install it between the water pump switch and the water pump.
Please see more details in the below link.
https://inspectapedia.com/electric/M...set_Button.php
My pump does not have that button so I want to create one.
I am assuming that it works when the motor is over working like pumping into a full water tank.
So I am thinking of installing a circuit breaker to do the same work.
I hope that it is clear and that someone can advice me on that idea.
I am planing to install it between the water pump switch and the water pump.
#11
Group Moderator
If you are located in the UAE are your Internet searches censored or restricted? Should we be providing manufacturer's links instead of US retail stores?
#12
You have a logistics or administrative problem as opposed to a plumbing or electrical problem.
Find a craftsman who can fabricate a float switch out of a toilet tank float/valve assembly.
Find a craftsman who can fabricate a float switch out of a toilet tank float/valve assembly.
Last edited by AllanJ; 05-27-20 at 03:46 PM.
#13
Member
You don't need a reset button. You need a simple on off switch controlled by a float switch. How many HP and volts is the pump? Is it single phase or 3 phase power? That will determine the size of the switch.
It's a fairly simple motor control circuit, except that you have a float switch in place of the start stop button.
It's a fairly simple motor control circuit, except that you have a float switch in place of the start stop button.
#14
motor overheating, thermal overload protection.
#15
Member
Thread Starter
The motor is over 10 years old. It has been overloading since about 2013. I am not sure how come it has not burned out yet.
Sometimes it keeps running for hours after the tank gets full. I was away for several years and now that I am back I am just trying to find an affordable way to stop it.
The other provided solutions are not available here.
Sometimes it keeps running for hours after the tank gets full. I was away for several years and now that I am back I am just trying to find an affordable way to stop it.
The other provided solutions are not available here.
#16
Member
I’m not sure that a centrifugal pump looking into a dead head will increase the torque. It may actually unload the motor.
#17
You just need to dig a little...........................
Here's a generic search page for you. I searched for "pumps floats in the UAE" and got many hits.
Pump float search in the UAE
The next link is to the exact part in the UAE......
Pump float
Here's a generic search page for you. I searched for "pumps floats in the UAE" and got many hits.
Pump float search in the UAE
The next link is to the exact part in the UAE......
Pump float
#18
Member
Thread Starter
I am not in the UAE anymore. I have left the UAE.
Thanks for all the great ideas provided to me.
I do think that the motor is getting overloaded because it sounds like it is about to explode when the tank gets full and the float valve is closed.
Since using a circuit breaker is a very cheap solution the residence here have agreed to try that idea and see if it works (I will be the one who will purchase and install it). I will post the results here once testing is done (some time next week).
I will put a circuit breaker that is of the exact same load of the maximum load of the water pump so that it reacts quickly to the overload.
After all this is DIY solutions which means anything should go and not just the official way of doing things. I don't think that inventions will exist if no one tried different things.
There is no need to fear new ideas.
Thanks for all the great ideas provided to me.
I do think that the motor is getting overloaded because it sounds like it is about to explode when the tank gets full and the float valve is closed.
Since using a circuit breaker is a very cheap solution the residence here have agreed to try that idea and see if it works (I will be the one who will purchase and install it). I will post the results here once testing is done (some time next week).
I will put a circuit breaker that is of the exact same load of the maximum load of the water pump so that it reacts quickly to the overload.
After all this is DIY solutions which means anything should go and not just the official way of doing things. I don't think that inventions will exist if no one tried different things.
There is no need to fear new ideas.
#19
It really should not be this complicated.
If you have a float switch controlled pump, when the tank is full the switch on the float should open the circuit that controls the pump to stop it..
It is likely not wired correctly.
Disconnect a wire on the float switch to see if this stops the motor.
If not you need an electrician to troubleshoot the problem and either repair the problem or rewire it.
If it ever worked the pump motor could have been wired directly to the float switch or in some commercial settings the float could control a relay that actually switches the motor.
If you have a float switch controlled pump, when the tank is full the switch on the float should open the circuit that controls the pump to stop it..
It is likely not wired correctly.
Disconnect a wire on the float switch to see if this stops the motor.
If not you need an electrician to troubleshoot the problem and either repair the problem or rewire it.
If it ever worked the pump motor could have been wired directly to the float switch or in some commercial settings the float could control a relay that actually switches the motor.
#20
Member
He said float valve not float switch. If a valve is shutting that would be putting extreme load and the pump pump water into a closed system. A pressure switch on the feed line could detect this pressure and shut off the pump.
#21
Member
Using a circuit breaker as an overload/switch will quickly shorten the life of the circuit breaker. I suspect you'll spend more money continuously replacing breakers vs. using a float switch or pressure switch.
#22
Ahh.
Then as other have said, a pressure switch along with a small pneumatic tank would be needed for the pump to shut off .
Then as other have said, a pressure switch along with a small pneumatic tank would be needed for the pump to shut off .
#23
After all this is DIY solutions which means anything should go and not just the official way of doing things. I don't think that inventions will exist if no one tried different things.
#24
Member
Thread Starter
Will not be able to do testing now. The required circuit breaker is not available locally.
Maybe I will order it online one day.
Maybe I will order it online one day.