Should I get MDF or Plywood?

Hello All,

I've searched the forums and learned lots but I'd still like some advice. I'm building a small end table, and need to choose between hardwood plywood and MDF for the tops. Obviously the MDF is cheaper. I don't have much experience with oil based paint, and have read that using any water based paint/primer on MDF is a bad idea. Is this true, or am I good as long as I primer it well? I have an airless sprayer that I'm also considering using. I'm really hoping to get a smooth finish without much texture. Any advice on materials and paint greatly appreciated!

 

I would suggest using MDO (medium density overlay) plywood for the best finish.

 

MDF paints nicely and I've never run into any issues using latex primer/paint on it but I agree with Furd, use MDO. MDF doesn't withstand much abuse and may show signs of wear quicker than plywood.
Oil base enamels dry to a harder film than latex enamels. Some of the cheaper latex enamels are prone to blocking - sticking when heavy items are set on them for an extended period of time.

 

Thanks guys. I ended up passing on the mdf. I figured a few extra bucks for at least the peace of mind was worth it.