How high can or should I run an old heating system?
#1
Member
Thread Starter
How high can or should I run an old heating system?
Just out of curiosity guys, we have a monster sized Thatcher 110k BTU Gas heater in this 70 year old house. I normally set the thermostat at 74 and leave it like that during the winter but on super cold and especially windy days, how high should I set it so as not to put too much strain on the heating system please?
#2
Hi, setting the stat higher will just make the heater run longer to try and maintain the set point, is this a furnace or boiler, not that it makes a difference.
Geo🇺🇸🇺🇸
Geo🇺🇸🇺🇸
#3
Member
Thread Starter
Hey, thanks for helping. Its a furnace but the age of the system is what has me being maybe overly cautious.
Most people I talk to says they set around 68-70 and I do 74 to compensate for this being an old house but for old houses how high might be a recommended max setting I should go to not to put too much strain on the system whenever needed please?
Most people I talk to says they set around 68-70 and I do 74 to compensate for this being an old house but for old houses how high might be a recommended max setting I should go to not to put too much strain on the system whenever needed please?
#5
Member
Thread Starter
Hmnn, never considered that to be honest because whoever had designed the heating ducting system in this house did a terrible job as different rooms has different temps or I should say one room will feel colder than another. I set at 74 because at that setting, normally has a comfortable feel in most of the rooms.
#6
Member
HVAC equipment has a 100% duty cycle. Meaning it can run continuously and be ok.
Your not really putting an extra strain on it, it’s not like driving a car with the throttle wide open everywhere.
Make sure and do seasonal maintenance and have the heat exchanger checked. That’s what causes most furnaces to go to the scrap yard and also what causes most carbon monoxide poisonings.
Your not really putting an extra strain on it, it’s not like driving a car with the throttle wide open everywhere.
Make sure and do seasonal maintenance and have the heat exchanger checked. That’s what causes most furnaces to go to the scrap yard and also what causes most carbon monoxide poisonings.
mikehende
voted this post useful.
#7
Group Moderator
The reason we ask what the temperature is (not how it feels, but the actual number) is to find out if the system is maxed out. If you have the heat set on 74f and the furnace is running continuously and the house is 68f then turning up the thermostat higher will not have any affect.
mikehende
voted this post useful.
#8
It's not really a strain just how much longer the unit has to run to try to keep that higher set point.
It could fail at any time regardless if it was set at 65 or 74.
It could fail at any time regardless if it was set at 65 or 74.
#9
Member
Thread Starter
ok thanks guys.
@Roughneck77
That is exactly what one boiler repair tech had said to me couple years ago when he had asked if I think the heating system is like an old car which will break down if I run it too hard?
Regarding the maintenance aspect, I had asked this of him and he had said "if it Ain;t broke don't tamper with it". I never liked hearing that tbh because what's one to do if/when it breaks and need to wait for an unspecified amount of time before someone should get here? I had considered calling an HVAC company who was charging only $80 to do a checkup.
So guess I should go from 74 to 80 now on super cold days.
@Roughneck77
That is exactly what one boiler repair tech had said to me couple years ago when he had asked if I think the heating system is like an old car which will break down if I run it too hard?
Regarding the maintenance aspect, I had asked this of him and he had said "if it Ain;t broke don't tamper with it". I never liked hearing that tbh because what's one to do if/when it breaks and need to wait for an unspecified amount of time before someone should get here? I had considered calling an HVAC company who was charging only $80 to do a checkup.
So guess I should go from 74 to 80 now on super cold days.
#10
So guess I should go from 74 to 80 now on super cold days.
You would benefit from some air sealing maintenance and also humidification to make it more comfortable not to mention saving some $.
#11
Member
Thread Starter
With a well insulated house that should be accurate, unfortunately for us, different story. only way for this old house will be to gut everything and totally insulate then put in new system but lack of finance for this has us doing whatever we can to survive.
#12
Member
DO NOT hire one of those cheap checkup services you see on billboards and hear on the radio. They are designed to get the companies foot in the door so they can sell you all kinds of equipment and parts. They are NOT designed to actually do any maintenance on your equipment.
You need a trustworthy company, preferably a small company with low overhead, to come in and do a full checkout. It’s mandatory to check the heat exchanger in an old furnace. A crack or rot can cause carbon monoxide poisoning which can kill you. Or make you very sick.
You need a trustworthy company, preferably a small company with low overhead, to come in and do a full checkout. It’s mandatory to check the heat exchanger in an old furnace. A crack or rot can cause carbon monoxide poisoning which can kill you. Or make you very sick.
#13
Member
Thread Starter
Thanks. I know another local repair guy who had repaired a bud's boiler last year who can do a checkup but wondering if I should call him "now" or wait unto after the winter or just before next winter please?
#14
Member
Originally Posted by mikehende
but on super cold and especially windy days, how high should I set it so as not to put too much strain on the heating system please?
setting the stat higher will just make the heater run longer to try and maintain the set point
Originally Posted by Geochurchi

BUT- if you have plumbing in or along an exterior wall (especially an addition) THEN you WILL want to up the temperature in that room (depending on how well insulated the wet-wall is).
Consider if you have an interior temperature of 72°F and it is 32°F outside, heat flow though the wall will put the center of the wall at around 52°F (halfway between the inside / outside temperature). If you get down to single digits, say 2°F then pipes in the center of the wall will start to freeze if the interior temperature drops below 62°F, as the interior of the wall drops to 32set F. (Yes, this is a MAJOR oversimplification).
This is DRASTICALLY magnified if you have direct cold air drafts (e.g. you feel cold air leaking in through electric outlets). Oddly enough, this ALSO means that the normal best practice of "sealing electric outlets" can backfire because the cold air can 'fill up' the interior wall space and find its way to pipes in that wall.
mikehende
voted this post useful.
#15
Member
Here is what I would do for an old furnace.
1. Buy a carbon monoxide detector and ut it close to the old furnace.
2. Do not tamper with it unless it is broken.
3. Set the shut off furnace temperature not too high. Let the furnace run a bit cooler when running.
4. Set the blower turn on temperature a bit lower.
5. Increase blower fan speed. That will run the heat exchanger a bit cooler
Basically make furnace run NOT TOO HOT.
1. Buy a carbon monoxide detector and ut it close to the old furnace.
2. Do not tamper with it unless it is broken.
3. Set the shut off furnace temperature not too high. Let the furnace run a bit cooler when running.
4. Set the blower turn on temperature a bit lower.
5. Increase blower fan speed. That will run the heat exchanger a bit cooler
Basically make furnace run NOT TOO HOT.
mikehende
voted this post useful.
#16
Member
Thread Starter
Thanks Sam, will mention all that you've written whenever I should someone come here to do maintenance.
However guys, I am always a prevention is better than cure kind of guy so my belief is in checking the system "before" the winter season at least every couple of years, replacing any parts which might start showing signs of breakage, anyone here agree with this please?
However guys, I am always a prevention is better than cure kind of guy so my belief is in checking the system "before" the winter season at least every couple of years, replacing any parts which might start showing signs of breakage, anyone here agree with this please?