Is Trane Worth The Price?please Help
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 3
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts




#2
Join Date: Aug 2002
Location: Mountain Williams Missouri
Posts: 17,505
Upvotes: 0
Received 1 Upvote
on
1 Post

Not there cant see it .Cost are a lot different all over . but that sounds ok to me.
Now Drop down there to a XL15i condenser unit
4 ton Stay with the V/S blower you will like it. Also go with the R22 the cost of the R410a is to high. The R22 will be made till 2030. So it will be around a longtime. Stay with it.
From the ### you gave Id say you have a 3.5 ton AC
With both inside and out you should have a 10 warranty on the Trane units.
That XL15i will have a SEER of 15.10 and going over the 15 seer you should be able to put in for a tax credit from the IRS for $300.
ED
Now Drop down there to a XL15i condenser unit
4 ton Stay with the V/S blower you will like it. Also go with the R22 the cost of the R410a is to high. The R22 will be made till 2030. So it will be around a longtime. Stay with it.
From the ### you gave Id say you have a 3.5 ton AC
With both inside and out you should have a 10 warranty on the Trane units.
That XL15i will have a SEER of 15.10 and going over the 15 seer you should be able to put in for a tax credit from the IRS for $300.
ED

#3
Member
Join Date: Feb 2005
Location: Southeast USA
Posts: 1,034
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
waterfrontdude
First of all, Trane's XL16i high eff 2 stg heat pump is a great system. I would prefer this over the XL15i HP which is a single stg heat pump. You should make certain with your dealer that your ductwork is sized OK for a 4 ton unit. I do not like using one system for both basement, main floor, and second floor. I suspect you have airflow issues along with hot/cold spots. These problems should be addressed by dealer and I would recommend zoning the basement/main floor and the second floor. Your dealer though must be experienced in zoning.
As far as prices go, this is difficult to tell because prices vary between markets. I personally believe price is somewhat higher than I would have expected but I don't know what quote includes. I do suggest that you purchase a whole house air filter cabinet like the Perfect Fit Media cabinet.
You may want to get a competitive quote on Carrier's Infinity Heat pump along with their zoning controls. I like Trane heat pumps better but I have to admit that Carrier Infinity systems have the most sophisticated system controls in the marketplace.
My opinion.
Good LucK!
First of all, Trane's XL16i high eff 2 stg heat pump is a great system. I would prefer this over the XL15i HP which is a single stg heat pump. You should make certain with your dealer that your ductwork is sized OK for a 4 ton unit. I do not like using one system for both basement, main floor, and second floor. I suspect you have airflow issues along with hot/cold spots. These problems should be addressed by dealer and I would recommend zoning the basement/main floor and the second floor. Your dealer though must be experienced in zoning.
As far as prices go, this is difficult to tell because prices vary between markets. I personally believe price is somewhat higher than I would have expected but I don't know what quote includes. I do suggest that you purchase a whole house air filter cabinet like the Perfect Fit Media cabinet.
You may want to get a competitive quote on Carrier's Infinity Heat pump along with their zoning controls. I like Trane heat pumps better but I have to admit that Carrier Infinity systems have the most sophisticated system controls in the marketplace.
My opinion.
Good LucK!
#4
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Jul 2006
Posts: 3
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts

Thank you ed and tiger both for your input on this.I only wish I would've found this forum earlier than the day before I was going to do this.I wasn't going to have another hot night of trying to sleep in front of a fan blowing hot air on me all night.
I did go over the duct size with them and they said it was well capable of handling a 4 ton unit.I never really had a problem with hot and cold spots(zoning) or aiflow issues the old unit,it just couldn't keep up before it died when it got really hot.I did get the xl16i and the v/s blower. It really wasn't that hot here yesterday but it sure was a comfortable night in this place lastnight.
I just hope this unit now lasts for many many years to come. I really didn't make it clear in my first post the unit is for the main and 2nd floor, the basement is not heated or cooled, it's not living space.(Atleast not yet anyway)
Thanks again guys for your input,Have a great day!!
Dave


Thanks again guys for your input,Have a great day!!
Dave