Honeywell HE260 vs General Air 1042
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
Honeywell HE260 vs General Air 1042
Anyone recommend one over the other? Or are they pretty much the same quality and performance?
Is it true the solenoid valve is unreliable on the Honewell units?
Cheers
Is it true the solenoid valve is unreliable on the Honewell units?
Cheers
#2
Is it true the solenoid valve is unreliable on the Honeywell units?
#3
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
Jay,
I've decided to stick with the HE260 and would like to not use the sail switch if possible. Ideally I would like the humidifier to operate when the blower operates. My furnace is a Trane XR90 and the transformer that came with my humidifier is a plug in type 120v/24v. Is it possible to wire the HE260 to the XR90 such that the activation of the blower also activates the humidifier?
Cheers and Thanks
I've decided to stick with the HE260 and would like to not use the sail switch if possible. Ideally I would like the humidifier to operate when the blower operates. My furnace is a Trane XR90 and the transformer that came with my humidifier is a plug in type 120v/24v. Is it possible to wire the HE260 to the XR90 such that the activation of the blower also activates the humidifier?
Cheers and Thanks
#4
Is it possible to wire the HE260 to the XR90 such that the activation of the blower also activates the humidifier?
#5
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
I already mounted the humidifier unit on the return and the bypass on the supply.
So what hardware do I need for hardwiring to furnace? Your help is greatly appreciated.......
#7
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
Nope, but I don't mind going to buy one as they are fairly cheap (10$ or so..)
#8
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
Another question, it seems like it is possible to reverse the sidewalls of the humidifier body such that the bypass port pionts left instead of right?
This would make installing the bypass ducting a little easier for me.
Cheers
This would make installing the bypass ducting a little easier for me.
Cheers
#9
Go head and buy a hard wired one. You can wire this in the power junction box that is inside on the left side of the furnace, there is a small knock out hole that you can mount the humidifier on.
Honeywell must of stopped putting the transformer in the box then?? (i'll have to check the ones we got at the store)
#10
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
Yes, there is a screw in back with the pad out, that you can remove, and switch sides.
Go head and buy a hard wired one. You can wire this in the power junction box that is inside on the left side of the furnace, there is a small knock out hole that you can mount the humidifier on.
Honeywell must of stopped putting the transformer in the box then?? (i'll have to check the ones we got at the store)
Go head and buy a hard wired one. You can wire this in the power junction box that is inside on the left side of the furnace, there is a small knock out hole that you can mount the humidifier on.
Honeywell must of stopped putting the transformer in the box then?? (i'll have to check the ones we got at the store)
I'll purchase the transformer tomorrow.
Cheers
#12
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts

Also I took your advice and will eventually switch my saddle valves to T-line. But for now I will install the saddle valve for the short term
#14
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
http://i222.photobucket.com/albums/d...x/IMG_0621.jpg
http://i222.photobucket.com/albums/d...x/IMG_0622.jpg
http://i222.photobucket.com/albums/d...x/IMG_0623.jpg
http://i222.photobucket.com/albums/d...x/IMG_0625.jpg
#15
You are good to go!
I noticed one thing.

On your return duct up further, there is an elbow coming out, and looks like it's tied to nothing??
Also I notice your intake pipe on the furnace is not going outside.
I noticed one thing.

On your return duct up further, there is an elbow coming out, and looks like it's tied to nothing??
Also I notice your intake pipe on the furnace is not going outside.
#16
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
As for the intake, is that not normal? (sorry if stupid question). This is a builder home and that is how they installed it. If it is wrong then I can get them to fix it.
Cheers
#17
Keep some open down there for air exchange, and also the warmth will help your living floor between the basement and living space upstairs.
As for th
Well, It's not normal, just not done often. Right now you are pulling air right out of your basement, air that you already have paid to heat. Also pulling in fumes that may be in the air, and what not in the air and can shorten the life of the heat exchanger.
Do you have a fresh air pipe in the basement near the water heater or furnace?
As for th
e intake, is that not normal? (sorry if stupid question). This is a builder home and that is how they installed it. If it is wrong then I can get them to fix it.
Do you have a fresh air pipe in the basement near the water heater or furnace?
#18
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
Thanks Jay, my builder is coming over to look at the furnace intake to see if it is installed properly (or at least to local code).
Back to the humidifier install:
1 - is it ok to install the humidistat 9" upstream from the humidifier body and 12" downstream from an elbow? Otherwise I have to install way upstream making wiring a hassle.
2 - The only 120/24 volt hardwire transformer I could by at HD was the following (made for Wait humidifier).

Will this work? So I connect the 120V (line) side to the juction box? (1 wire to EAC and the other to White) and then wire the humidistat and humidifier?
3 - Is there warranty concerns when adding wiring to the furnace junction box?
Back to the humidifier install:
1 - is it ok to install the humidistat 9" upstream from the humidifier body and 12" downstream from an elbow? Otherwise I have to install way upstream making wiring a hassle.
2 - The only 120/24 volt hardwire transformer I could by at HD was the following (made for Wait humidifier).

Will this work? So I connect the 120V (line) side to the juction box? (1 wire to EAC and the other to White) and then wire the humidistat and humidifier?
3 - Is there warranty concerns when adding wiring to the furnace junction box?
#19
1 - is it ok to install the humidistat 9" upstream from the humidifier body and 12" downstream from an elbow? Otherwise I have to install way upstream making wiring a hassle.
2 - The only 120/24 volt hardwire transformer I could by at HD was the following (made for Wait humidifier).

So I connect the 120V (line) side to the juction box? (1 wire to EAC and the other to White) and then wire the humidistat and humidifier?
3 - Is there warranty concerns when adding wiring to the furnace junction box?
#20
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: Canada
Posts: 95
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
There is about 25inches of space from the top of the humidifier to the T-branch (term?) in the return line (see pic). So to maintain the minimum 8" clearance the humidistat would be mounted about 9" from the humidifier body and 12" from the T-branch.

#21
Perfect spot for it. You can mount it above it or on the back side for easy setting of dial.
FYI, you can hide/run the wire inside the duct work to give you the clean run.
FYI, you can hide/run the wire inside the duct work to give you the clean run.
#24
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: oakville, ontario, canada
Posts: 14
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
sweet - just found this thread - i've got a trane xr90 as well, and picked up a honeywell he260A today (local hvac guy wanted $500+ to put in a generalaire1042). my house is about 3,400 sq ft, in oakville, ontario. just moved into the new house this month, and so far humidity is still 30% - 32%, but i'm pretty sure i'll need a humidifier to keep it over 35% as the winter gets colder.
this thread has already answered most of my questions, but i still have a few:
1 - i've got limited space on the warm air supply (the return duct goes down & under the furnace so the furnace is already mounted higher than normal)- i definitely can't mount the humidifer on it, but can squeeze the bypass duct in there. any issues with that set up? (any risk of blowing water droplets into the return ducting?).
2 - can the bypass duct be installed between the blower and the a/c coil? i might be able to get it above (after) the a/c coil, but it's pretty tight for space up there.
3 - for the return, should i use the cheap flex duct that came with the kit, or should i use some aluminum flex duct or should i do it the hard way with galvanized ducting and elbows?
4 (a) - i'd love to get a nice thermostat with humidity control, and hook the humidifier up to that rather than the cheap humidistat in the box - i can order a robertshaw9801i online pretty cheap, but is there anything you'd recommend? (or should i just put in a cool looking visionpro and leave the humidistat on the duct, as i only have single stage heat/cool?)
4(b) - is there a thermostat i can program to run the furnace fan slower when i need dehumidification more than cooling (or is this not possible with my furnace?), and can i set it to run the fan about 30% of the time when heat/cool is not called for in order to supply additional circulation (or additional humidity if needed), as i don't have a dc fan motor?
5 - the furnace filter size for my return ducting is 18x25. the builder had put in a 16x25 filter and there was a 2" gap. my local hd guy hasn't heard of 18x25. do 18x25 filters actually exist, or did the builder screw up? what can i do for this?
6 - how much better is it to use hot water than cold?
7 - if i use hot water, should i be cutting the 25' plastic hose down to the minimum required in order to maintain heat?
8- any chance a compression fit tee and proper ball valve will flow too much water compared to the saddle valve included in the kit? (i just replaced the saddle valve for the fridge water line today with a proper ball valve on a compression fitting tee - only hard part was getting the tee body in-line when the cut out was pretty close to another joint in the pipe - not so flexible at that point).
9 - does the he260A put out enough humidity for a house of this size or should i be looking at something else? (i already called around and can't find a truesteam unit anywhere)
thanks in advance...
this thread has already answered most of my questions, but i still have a few:
1 - i've got limited space on the warm air supply (the return duct goes down & under the furnace so the furnace is already mounted higher than normal)- i definitely can't mount the humidifer on it, but can squeeze the bypass duct in there. any issues with that set up? (any risk of blowing water droplets into the return ducting?).
2 - can the bypass duct be installed between the blower and the a/c coil? i might be able to get it above (after) the a/c coil, but it's pretty tight for space up there.
3 - for the return, should i use the cheap flex duct that came with the kit, or should i use some aluminum flex duct or should i do it the hard way with galvanized ducting and elbows?
4 (a) - i'd love to get a nice thermostat with humidity control, and hook the humidifier up to that rather than the cheap humidistat in the box - i can order a robertshaw9801i online pretty cheap, but is there anything you'd recommend? (or should i just put in a cool looking visionpro and leave the humidistat on the duct, as i only have single stage heat/cool?)
4(b) - is there a thermostat i can program to run the furnace fan slower when i need dehumidification more than cooling (or is this not possible with my furnace?), and can i set it to run the fan about 30% of the time when heat/cool is not called for in order to supply additional circulation (or additional humidity if needed), as i don't have a dc fan motor?
5 - the furnace filter size for my return ducting is 18x25. the builder had put in a 16x25 filter and there was a 2" gap. my local hd guy hasn't heard of 18x25. do 18x25 filters actually exist, or did the builder screw up? what can i do for this?
6 - how much better is it to use hot water than cold?
7 - if i use hot water, should i be cutting the 25' plastic hose down to the minimum required in order to maintain heat?
8- any chance a compression fit tee and proper ball valve will flow too much water compared to the saddle valve included in the kit? (i just replaced the saddle valve for the fridge water line today with a proper ball valve on a compression fitting tee - only hard part was getting the tee body in-line when the cut out was pretty close to another joint in the pipe - not so flexible at that point).
9 - does the he260A put out enough humidity for a house of this size or should i be looking at something else? (i already called around and can't find a truesteam unit anywhere)
thanks in advance...
#25
1 - i've got limited space on the warm air supply (the return duct goes down & under the furnace so the furnace is already mounted higher than normal)- i definitely can't mount the humidifer on it, but can squeeze the bypass duct in there. any issues with that set up? (any risk of blowing water droplets into the return ducting?).
2 - can the bypass duct be installed between the blower and the a/c coil? i might be able to get it above (after) the a/c coil, but it's pretty tight for space up there.
3 - for the return, should i use the cheap flex duct that came with the kit, or should i use some aluminum flex duct or should i do it the hard way with galvanized ducting and elbows?
4 (a) - i'd love to get a nice thermostat with humidity control, and hook the humidifier up to that rather than the cheap humidistat in the box - i can order a robertshaw9801i online pretty cheap, but is there anything you'd recommend? (or should i just put in a cool looking visionpro and leave the humidistat on the duct, as i only have single stage heat/cool?)
4(b) - is there a thermostat i can program to run the furnace fan slower when i need dehumidification more than cooling (or is this not possible with my furnace?), and can i set it to run the fan about 30% of the time when heat/cool is not called for in order to supply additional circulation (or additional humidity if needed), as i don't have a dc fan motor?
5 - the furnace filter size for my return ducting is 18x25. the builder had put in a 16x25 filter and there was a 2" gap. my local hd guy hasn't heard of 18x25. do 18x25 filters actually exist, or did the builder screw up? what can i do for this?
6 - how much better is it to use hot water than cold?
7 - if i use hot water, should i be cutting the 25' plastic hose down to the minimum required in order to maintain heat?
8- any chance a compression fit tee and proper ball valve will flow too much water compared to the saddle valve included in the kit? (i just replaced the saddle valve for the fridge water line today with a proper ball valve on a compression fitting tee - only hard part was getting the tee body in-line when the cut out was pretty close to another joint in the pipe - not so flexible at that point).
9 - does the he260A put out enough humidity for a house of this size or should i be looking at something else? (i already called around and can't find a truesteam unit anywhere)
thanks in advance...[/QUOTE]
#26
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: oakville, ontario, canada
Posts: 14
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
I picked up a honeywell RTH8500 at the local hardware store - was hoping it had the same functionality as the VisionPro TH8110, then i found the following differences:
Can't use remote sensors (indoor or outdoor)
Not able to use 24vAC for power (all power from the AAA's)
Not able to work without batteries
No continuous backlight
No auto-changeover
No circulation mode on the fan/blower
Fan mode isn't programmable
Can't handle multi-stage HP installs
No cycle/anticipator adjustment for cooling, very limited adjustment for heating
Requires an external fossil fuel kit when used with a heat pump
Not able to intelligently decide when to use HP & when to use aux/emergency heat b/c it lacks an outdoor temp sensor
No humidity control
No temperature limits
Won't handle 3 heat/2 cooling stage systems
Only has service indicator for filter change, none for UV lamp / humidifier pad / etc.
Can't adjust minimum time between cycles
Can't set upper/lower temp limits for heating & cooling
Can't adjust fan on after heating/cooling
Can't lock out keypad
Can't adjust adaptive recovery compensation
Now I know that the RTH does have autochangeover, so i'm hoping there are other inacurracies, as I do want the circulation mode, and i'd like the continuous backlight. Does anyone know for sure? Also, can i pop it off the wall to program it and the pop it back on when i'm done?
Can't use remote sensors (indoor or outdoor)
Not able to use 24vAC for power (all power from the AAA's)
Not able to work without batteries
No continuous backlight
No auto-changeover
No circulation mode on the fan/blower
Fan mode isn't programmable
Can't handle multi-stage HP installs
No cycle/anticipator adjustment for cooling, very limited adjustment for heating
Requires an external fossil fuel kit when used with a heat pump
Not able to intelligently decide when to use HP & when to use aux/emergency heat b/c it lacks an outdoor temp sensor
No humidity control
No temperature limits
Won't handle 3 heat/2 cooling stage systems
Only has service indicator for filter change, none for UV lamp / humidifier pad / etc.
Can't adjust minimum time between cycles
Can't set upper/lower temp limits for heating & cooling
Can't adjust fan on after heating/cooling
Can't lock out keypad
Can't adjust adaptive recovery compensation
Now I know that the RTH does have autochangeover, so i'm hoping there are other inacurracies, as I do want the circulation mode, and i'd like the continuous backlight. Does anyone know for sure? Also, can i pop it off the wall to program it and the pop it back on when i'm done?
#27
Yes, on the TH8110, you can program the fan mode, and also pop it off the wall to program it with the batteries in. And if the C wire is hooked up the back screen light works, and the battery will last longer.
#28
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: oakville, ontario, canada
Posts: 14
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
got the TH8110 - that is one sweet thermostat. unfortunately my builder used only a 4 conductor thermostat control cable, so no wire free to hook up to the 18v common. if i want to run a new wire, what gauge should i use?
#29
You will need an 18 gauge t-stat wire. I would fish up 8 wires that way it's ready for something down the road if upgraded to say two stage furnace w/ two stage A/C or heat pump.
#33
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: oakville, ontario, canada
Posts: 14
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
i've got plenty of 22 awg cat5 network cable. how many of the 22awg conductors do i need to splice together to carry enough current to run the common to power the backlight?
#35
Member
Join Date: Dec 2007
Location: oakville, ontario, canada
Posts: 14
Received 0 Votes
on
0 Posts
ok, hooked it up with a new run of 5 conductor 18g wire - works and looks great.
another question: i can get either a truesteam humidifier or the honeywell 260.
is the truesteam any better? can i install the truesteam on my own?
i don't see any free connectors on the furnace's main board - just the screws where i wired in the thermostat. i don't want to use a sail switch, how can i wire it up to my trane xr90?
there is a transformer there already - should i tap into that somehow?
another question: i can get either a truesteam humidifier or the honeywell 260.
is the truesteam any better? can i install the truesteam on my own?
i don't see any free connectors on the furnace's main board - just the screws where i wired in the thermostat. i don't want to use a sail switch, how can i wire it up to my trane xr90?
there is a transformer there already - should i tap into that somehow?
#36
Inside on the left side there is an electrical junction box where you can wire up a transformer for the humidifier.. There is two wires, one for HUM and other for EAC.
Here is a shot of mine.

The TrueSTEAM is coming out, but on a lag till end of March, I would go for it if your water rates are very high. My area, water rates is pretty cheap, and cost us about $30 a heatingn season to run my flow though.
Here is a shot of mine.

The TrueSTEAM is coming out, but on a lag till end of March, I would go for it if your water rates are very high. My area, water rates is pretty cheap, and cost us about $30 a heatingn season to run my flow though.