Ceiling light, switch wired to neutral. Measuring ~V with switch on and off
#1
02-11-12, 06:01 PM
Ceiling light, switch wired to neutral. Measuring ~V with switch on and off
Hi All,
I am replacing a light fixture with a ceiling fan. When I measure the hot black wire with respect to neutral with multimeter I am reading ~120V whether the switch is on or off. I spoke to an electrician who insured me that this is because the switch is actually switching the neutral and NOT the hot wire. This makes sense to me.
What I am confused about is this: If I am measuring ~120VAC with the switch open or closed (between the hot and neutral wires with the fixture not hooked up), then why when I hook the light up does it still turn on and off with the switch?
I would think that if I can measure voltage off of the bare wires regardless of the switch position then the light should be on regardless of the switch position but this is not the case. When I have the fixture hooked up it does turn off when the switch is off!!!
I am replacing a light fixture with a ceiling fan. When I measure the hot black wire with respect to neutral with multimeter I am reading ~120V whether the switch is on or off. I spoke to an electrician who insured me that this is because the switch is actually switching the neutral and NOT the hot wire. This makes sense to me.
What I am confused about is this: If I am measuring ~120VAC with the switch open or closed (between the hot and neutral wires with the fixture not hooked up), then why when I hook the light up does it still turn on and off with the switch?
I would think that if I can measure voltage off of the bare wires regardless of the switch position then the light should be on regardless of the switch position but this is not the case. When I have the fixture hooked up it does turn off when the switch is off!!!
#2
02-11-12, 08:22 PM
When I measure the hot black wire with respect to neutral with multimeter I am reading ~120V whether the switch is on or off. I spoke to an electrician who insured me that this is because the switch is actually switching the neutral and NOT the hot wire. This makes sense to me.
I would think that if I can measure voltage off of the bare wires regardless of the switch position then the light should be on regardless of the switch position but this is not the case.
#3
02-15-12, 01:47 PM
It was not unusual for wiring done before 1940 to have a switch in the neutral rather than in the hot line. You can leave it that way if you replace the light fixture only. If you modify the wiring you must correct it with the neutral continuous to the light fixture, and only the hot wire connected to the switch.
Is the switch handle "illuminated" with a small incandescent lamp, to light up when the main light is off? This will cause 120 volts to show through between hot and neutral with the switch in either position and the main light removed, when you use a voltmeter. WIth the main light wired up, hot to neutral across the light will register approximately zero volts with the switch "off".
Is the switch handle "illuminated" with a small incandescent lamp, to light up when the main light is off? This will cause 120 volts to show through between hot and neutral with the switch in either position and the main light removed, when you use a voltmeter. WIth the main light wired up, hot to neutral across the light will register approximately zero volts with the switch "off".
