What would you do with these stains on your white oak floor?
We had a rug in our entryway that deteriorated from getting wet from winter boots, etc. and actually adhered itself to the floor. I sort of scraped it off - took hours - and it left these dark stains. It was a Chilewich rug with rubberized bottom if that is useful. Anyway, we covered it up with another rug for a while, but now we're doing some work in the area and I'm wondering if there's something else I could do that won't be too much of an ordeal.
The entryway itself is small (4x10' or so), but it connects directly, without a threshold, to a larger area that's about 160 sq. ft. It's solid white oak and has a non-oil finish on it. Anyone have recommendations for getting the stains out? Chemical this or that? I considered sanding just this 4x10 area, maybe with a large sanding pad on a pole + my palm sander, but I would assume the transition to the rest of the adjoining room would be tricky or impossible to make look nice (?). And I actually don't know how deep the stains go, so might be unrealistic in thinking a little sanding will lift them out.
What would you do? Anything I should try first that just might make a big difference before committing to a bigger job? Maybe just cover it back up again?
^ When we first pulled up the rug, but before scraping all the rubber crud (a few yrs ago) ^ What it looks like now ^ zoomed
Thanks for the reply, Marq1. What would you use to try to get the stain up before going to the sand/refinish option? Also, do you reckon I have to do the whole area shown + the adjoining area, or is there some way to just do the affected area with not-too-noticeable transition?
Can you still feel the backing in the bottom pics? If so I'd try a wet thinner rag along with a lot of elbow grease. IMO refinishing the floor should be a last resort. If you do just the foyer the finish difference will show although it will still look better than it currently does.
We have three rooms of 1960's solid white oak flooring currently clear finished [unstained]. We're going to buy more white oak for two more rooms. Then, we will stain all five rooms a medium/darkish brown.
The current floors are #1 common. It would be nice to save money with #2 common for the new flooring, but don't want an obvious cheaper looking/lower quality appearing floor. One vendor said that stained we won't see a difference between #1 common and #2 common.
Looking for opinions. With the color range we are looking at staining, will the difference in grade be apparent?
Also, how much do grades vary between manufacturers, meaning do some pass-off lower grade pieces as higher grade more than others?
Thanks guys!
I am renovating my home gym which has 2 doors and can be completely closed off from the rest of the basement. The gym has several heavy machines (treadmill, peloton, water rower, elliptical) and dumbbell rack. I wanted to replace the existing rug with the black rubber mat ala gym type but the wife/boss wants to extend the vinyl flooring throughout and then use black mats as needed. My concerns is the black rubber mat will leave stains/damage the new flooring and given the number of equipment and weights would basically cover the entire floor anyhow. Maybe EVA foam? Lastly, (link removed) says I need 3/4" but most gym tile I see is 1/2" or less. I won't be slamming weights on the ground but don't want to leave indentations, marks, etc..