Clack WS1 v. North Star 30,000
#1
11-23-09, 11:57 AM
Clack WS1 v. North Star 30,000
Hi. We are looking to replace our Waterboss water softener that broke on us after five years (valve broke for second time). We have a water hardness of 12. We are a family of 4 (2 adults and 2 children under 5 years old). Anyone have any thoughts on either of these or recommend another system. Price range is under $650. Thanks!
#2
11-23-09, 12:19 PM
The Clack is a better valve than the North Star, but I don't like electronics on water softeners. The best choice would be a Fleck 5600 Meter demand system for the same cost. It will last longer with no electronics to go bad.
#3
11-23-09, 02:10 PM
If all you're removing is 12 grains hardness - no iron - then almost any softener will handle that application. I like limited electronic units because they usually offer battery back-up for single tank units so that when a power outage occurs you don't have to go down and set the correct time.
The Clack is a newer brand but seems to be gaining popularity. I use GE Autotrol valves because in my opinion they require the least amount of service over their lives.
The Clack is a newer brand but seems to be gaining popularity. I use GE Autotrol valves because in my opinion they require the least amount of service over their lives.
