need help: Approx. Cost to replace Well Holding Tank??
#1
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 73
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
need help: Approx. Cost to replace Well Holding Tank??
We have 16 year old 20 Gallon well holding tank that is getting rusty and also squealing almost every time. I know a 20G replacement tank is only $200-225, but as you can see from the picture we probably need new pressure guage and switch per the plumber. Plus the area is very tight, it's in the boiler room in the garage. I got estimate from local plumber (we know a little) for ~ $750. Seemed ok to me, but possibly a bit high?? please let me know your thoughts, we are in northern NJ and need to get this done. And I do not want to attempt on my own. thanks
#2
Member
Join Date: Mar 2006
Location: Mid-Florida
Posts: 1,201
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
The switch costs $20-30. The gauge costs $10(?) to $20.
Now you know what he charges for labor and he has to pay a helper.
May I make a suggestion? Call a well man, not a plumber, and ask him what he will charge. You need a well man anyway for your well.
People will say here that you can do it yourself, and you can, but it's hard without help or if you are not skilled with pipes.
Here is a very good page that describes the whole process in detail. You should look so you can see what someone else will do.
Replacing A Pressure Tank On A Residential Water Well System
I just noticed this not on the page:
Time Taken: About 6 Hours
I would have guessed about 4, but I often underestimate.
Now you know what he charges for labor and he has to pay a helper.
May I make a suggestion? Call a well man, not a plumber, and ask him what he will charge. You need a well man anyway for your well.
People will say here that you can do it yourself, and you can, but it's hard without help or if you are not skilled with pipes.
Here is a very good page that describes the whole process in detail. You should look so you can see what someone else will do.
Replacing A Pressure Tank On A Residential Water Well System
I just noticed this not on the page:
Time Taken: About 6 Hours
I would have guessed about 4, but I often underestimate.
#3
Group Moderator
Lots of variables and we don't get to be on site to evaluate; best practice is to get three or more bids so you can compare.
#4
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 73
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
thanks for initial replies so quick. I think most plumbers in northern NJ charge ~$100 per hour... does that seem right?? Thats why I'm thinking the $750estimate is not too far off if a 4 hour job. Don't think he has any helpers, we used him 1x before for a walk-in shower converted from bath-tub. But I'm getting a 2nd estimate Wed morning so we'll see how that goes.
#5
Group Moderator
$100/hour seems high to me but our NJ plumbing expert has mentioned prices in NJ being pretty high so this may be ok.
#6
Forum Topic Moderator
It doesn't seem out of control. If you've been happy with his work in the past, that's probably a good enough reason to use him even if it means paying a bit more. I've run into a couple plumbers here in NJ who I wouldn't invite back into my house... (but it's the same with most trades too)
I'd ask him to replace your valve with a new one. As valves age, they tend to not close as well and a new ball valve may provide you a bit more volume in the house. As long as everything else is changing, why not?
I'd ask him to replace your valve with a new one. As valves age, they tend to not close as well and a new ball valve may provide you a bit more volume in the house. As long as everything else is changing, why not?
#7
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 73
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
thanks Zorfdt... Yesterday we did get 2nd estimate that came in at $825. I asked the 1st plumber this morning if he could come down a bit, getting back to me later. The most challenging factor is the tight working area. He talked about moving the piping out front for easier access in future and also moving the electrical supply
#8
Member
Thread Starter
Join Date: Dec 2006
Location: Northern NJ
Posts: 73
Upvotes: 0
Received 0 Upvotes
on
0 Posts
quick update: Plumber #1 said even though Job will be 3-3.5 hours (its very tight working area) he agreed to do for $700. Said minimal profit is in there, but my wife is full-time Realtor and she has provided clients to him over past 2 years. He also is intstalling a new T-Fitting kit as part of this. Plus will move water pipes & electrical supply more to the front for future easier access.
thx again everyone...
thx again everyone...