Hot Topics: Are These Gutters Even Worth Repairing?

Lead Image

Here on we enjoy providing a place where home improvement novices and experts can come together to share ideas and advice. Inside our Forums, users can browse threads to see what exchanges are taking place on a topic of interest or start their own dialogue by posting something for the community to take part in. With over 250,000 members and counting, this resource is quite active, so each week we highlight one of the conversations that may just help you with your next DIY project.

When is it time to let go of grungy old gutters and spring for healthy new ones? And once you've decided your gutters need replacing, how do you know which gutters are the most effective and budget friendly? Trusting the experts is one way to go, another is to trust other homeowners who have been in the same boat as you. Our forum regulars have seen success and failures as homeowners and industry professionals. Take their advice...

Original Post: Gutters Overflowing - Should I Replace or Repair?

endeavour Member


I bought this house recently, and I am not sure what kind of gutters I have; please see pictures for reference. They are some kind of metal gutters and seem very sturdy. Does anyone know what kind of gutters these are?

overflowing gutters

They are overflowing at couple of spots. I have tried to clean them, but there is years of dust settled on the surface - probably the old owner didn't clean them regularly. I wanted to know if I should salvage the gutters and get them professionally cleaned or get them replaced?

Also, as you can tell, I don't know too much about gutters, so if you were to replace them, what kind of gutters would you recommend?

Highlights from the Thread

endeavour Member

Those are ancient pg gutters. Pg = pure garbage. A 5" k stule gutter will hold 3x the water and won't overflow. 3x4 downspouts will move 2x the water that 2x3 downspouts will.

Yes, I'd say new seamless gutters are in order, and you may want better drip edge over the gutters if yours is the short kind. You want what's called gutter apron.

aka pedro Member

Yes, standard K's, and while this is a DIY site, note that X said seamless, because this is one of those tasks that you can actually hire done. Have the pros roll it out to length on site and hang it for very close to what you would spend to buy just the material and have extra joints to deal with down the road.

As long as you can and are willing to clean them a few times a year, my opinion is to skip the gutter guards. They're something that can be added later if you decide that they're warranted, but they are not the be all end all that you completely ignore because things do get past them, so the gutters still need periodic cleaning. Just one man's opinions.

NWGraham Member

With my limited experience, I vote "yes" to gutter guards. I had both gutters and gutter guards installed on my house five years ago and have not had any problems with them.

I don't know how they would perform with different types of trees, but the leaves from the trembling aspen beside my house blow right off them. I haven't had any problems at all. But you might want to research how guards perform for the types of trees you have around your house - I have no experience with conifers, for example.

I don't know what type of guard you are looking at, but I live in a small town and the gutter-installers in the area only offered the regular gutters. My guards are the typical after-market guards (perforated, about 4 feet in length, screwed to the top of the gutter).

I was thinking last fall that I might need to unscrew them at some point to scrub off some moss, but they've already paid for themselves with the zero maintenance they've needed so far...

Read more here: //