Metal Roofing Shingles Vs. Wood Shingles

Metal roofing shingles can help you create an excellent roof for your home. Aluminum, stainless steel, tin and copper are some of the materials commonly used to produce these shingles. They make a good alternative to metal sheets or corrugated metal panels for roofing purposes. You may want to consider metal shingles as an alternative to the more traditional wood shingles. Below is a comparison of both to help you make a choice that best meets your needs.

Metal Roofing Shingles Advantages

Durability is one of the strongest points in favor of metal shingles. In many cases, the shingles can last beyond a century. They do not warp or split. Unlike wood, metal shingles aren’t affected by mold, insect infestation or rot. They can withstand high winds and effectively keep out moisture. This contributes to a lower maintenance level and replacement rate. The shingles also have a high resistance to fire which increases safety for your home. Metal shingles give you a versatility that is hard for wood shingles to match. The shingles can be produced with a rugged texture or wood grain similar to that on wood shingles. A wide range of colors is also available. This gives you higher design flexibility in the look you wish to create for your home. Metal shingles can also help you improve the energy efficiency of your home. They lower the costs of summer cooling by as much as 20 percent.


The high cost of metal shingles may be a deterrent to acquisition. It is also best to have a professional undertake the installation for you because of the complexities involved. This adds to overall costs. If you want a roof that contributes to a quiet home environment, metal shingles may not be the right choice for you. They generate more noise than wood shingles, especially during heavy rainfall or hailstorms.

Wood Shingles Advantages

The appeal of wood and array of natural colors helps to give your home a warm and naturally attractive look. This adds value to your home. Wood shingles present a more affordable option than metal shingles. Installation also isn’t as complex as that involved for metal shingles. This makes wood shingles an attractive choice to homeowners. You can undertake installation as a project yourself with the help of a few people. It helps to keep your budget down. It is also easier to undertake repair of wood shingles than metal shingles. This gives you a higher degree of independence in management of your property.


Durability for wood shingles is much lower than that of metal. Wood doesn’t have a high resistance to moisture. It can easily split and warp due to moisture and temperature effects. You must take steps to guard against such damage. This increases the maintenance requirements of wood shingles. Wood shingles are also subject to rot and insect infestation. Mold and mildew frequently attack the shingles which necessitates regular maintenance work. This pushes your home improvement budget up. Finally, wood shingles have a low resistance to fire unless pressure treated. This makes them unsuitable especially if you live in a fire prone area.